Nothing much changes…

It’s been a while since I’ve written about City Council. And after last night’s meeting, I decided I wouldn’t mind trying to get back at it. Why not start with a 4 1/2 hour meeting?

First of all, this Council just approved a local improvement plan to get the additional 30% funding from a segment of the tax base in the City. What do I mean by that? Well, you may want to get on the City’s website or take a nice spring walk down to City Hall and determine if you have cast-iron water lines providing you with water to your home, which for some, have reached their 100-year life span. If you are one of the lucky ones who has cast-iron lines, be ready. You’re going to pay more. Maybe not right away, but your cast-iron water line is on the radar over the next 20 years.

But I’m not. We don’t have cast-iron lines coming to our house. Let me use myself as an example of how this is going to play out.

I like the rest of you will be paying my share of the 70% cost oof $117million to replace the city’s cast-iron water lines. This comes in the form of a set tax increase, already in place and other funding sources through the budget. Administration is estimating that the entire project will cost $117million over the next 20 years. They haven’t taken into account any inflationary pressures which could lead it to around and over the $177million mark, but…I digress…

If you are one of the lucky ones, and have cast-iron water lines, you are now on the “list” to have your water line replaced. Whether it needs it or not. Meaning, if it’s not broken, the City is going to fix it anyways. It’s reaching it’s 100-year life span. It needs replacing. Currently, policy states that  if your water line blows from the main line  to your property line, it is your cost. So, if my water line breaks, I will be paying the cost. But only if it breaks. I am not part of the ‘new’ local improvement program noted above. I’ll reinterate. I do NOT have cast-iron water lines connected to my home.

So some of the taxpayers of Moose Jaw, will be paying 30% of the $117million cost and some will not.

Fair wouldn’t you say? I say no.

As I mentioned at the meeting last night, this is not an easy decision. But one I would be prepared to have a dedicated tax increase allocated to across the board (as is already in place) ALONG WITH reduced spending at City Hall. We have long been placing our wants above the needs of this community and it really is time to reign in spending. Now I realize that some may believe that we can’t cut costs anywhere but I would urge you to try and get through one of our budget binders and add up the number of consultants we have hired over the years to provide us with expert advice on all kinds of issues. That’s only one area where the fat could be trimmed. Municipal govenments are beacons for hiring consultants because ‘we don’t have the expertise to determine the best course of action’. Blah blah…

I’ll sum up the decision last night of instituting a local improvement program to replace these lines. There was a gentleman in the gallery until the end of the meeting watching the proceedings. He stood up at the end and said…”this Council should be ashamed of themselves for the decision they just made.” This is not going to go over well once the intricacies of this plays out in the community. Not taking responsibility for past ignorance on infrastructure and asking some citizens to pay more is starting to become all too typical for municipal councils.


On another note, I gave notice of motion last night to remove a clause to prohibit video from being taken during our public meetings. And to sum it up, this Council once again looks at something I bring forward and makes a mockery of it. A few weeks ago the Times-Herald uploaded a video to their Facebook page, from a public meeting in the Scoop Lewry Room and I thought it was fantastic. Turns out, said reporter was told by City Hall that he had “violated” the Decorum in Council Chambers bylaw. Hogwash I say.

So I brought foward notice of motion to allow video in Chambers (and otherwise) during our public meetings to be more accountable to our constituents. In this day and age everyone has a smart phone, with video capability, and with the introduction of Periscope (a live streaming app), I thought this would be a fantastic way to get our Executive meetings’ discussions out to more people. I thought I would try and do it myself during our public meetings in the Scoop Lewry Room! I am a huge fan of getting more information out to citizens and videos of our meetings and/or live streaming to me makes complete sense.

Well, I should know better than to try and make a change. This Council decided to refer the motion to administration for a report from policy to determine next actions. What a joke! In the whole scheme of things, this really is not the biggest issue Council should be dealing with BUT all councils should be open to being ACCOUNTABLE and TRANSPARENT. Doesn’t seem to be that way here in Moose Jaw. Councillor Kirkpatrick even said that she had “hoped it wouldn’t even be seconded” and then actually assumed from my motion that I was going to violate the Cities Act and stream IN-CAMERA/PRIVATE meetings! Where do these comments even come from? It really is unbelievable at times.

Oh, and Councillor, when you respect your other colleagues on Council, protocol that I’m familiar with says you second the notice of motion to allow it to come to the floor and be debated. You then have a right to vote against it if you wish. But allow your colleagues to have their say and express their opinions. 

Time will tell if this Council will allow citizens to join our meetings that are held publicly outside of Council Chambers by way of video clips or streams. As someone said on Twitter Sunday after the Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather fight, “I watched the fight on Periscope and saw the future”.

Maybe this Council will see the light and let even more of you see the discussions that go on outside of Council Chambers.  After some of the decisions that were made last night, you all deserve to hear and know more from your elected officials.
Have a happy Tuesday!

2 replies
  1. cathy Ulmer
    cathy Ulmer says:

    Hi Dawn. I attended a cast iron meeting, answered the survey, emailed city hall and asked many questions. Also watched most of council last nite. Would like to speak to you about it when you have time. Thanks. Cathy Ulmer

  2. Bill
    Bill says:

    I paid almost $3,000 to get my water & sewer done a few years back to my house. I was told that was half because the City “Split” the cost.
    If there is NO Policy on Video than people will tape meetings.
    I too feel that every time Council has Private, Closed Door Meetings that Secret Things are Given to “Special People”.
    I’ve been to Executive Meetings & had to sit outside of room so Council could deal with a “Secret Matter”


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *